Preliminary
note: The following is a draft of a working document, posted here in order
to become an object of discussion, re-thinking, and revision. We strongly
discourage any use or attribution of the following language that does not
take great care to represent it accurately.
WPA '98 OUTCOMES STATEMENT FOR FIRST-YEAR COMPOSITION
REVISED DRAFT [July 18th Version]
Introduction
By defining the common knowledge, skills, and attitudes sought by the wide
variety of approaches to first-year composition currently used in American
post-secondary education, we seek to describe a set of common outcomes
for those first-year composition classes. Recognizing that different institutions
aim at different levels of achievement for their students, we have not
attempted to define "standards," or precise levels of ability. Standards
should be left for specific institutions or specific groups of institutions
that might wish to set common standards. To some extent, then, we do seek
to regularize what can be expected to be taught in first-year composition,
and to this end the document is not a mere compilation or summary of what
currently takes place. Rather, the following outcomes are a careful integration
of practice, research, and theory.
Learning to write is a complex, individualized process which takes place
over time with continued practice. Understanding this, it is important
that teachers, administrators, and a concerned public do not imagine that
these outcomes can be taught in reduced or simple ways. Rather, gaining
these outcomes requires expert understanding of how students actually learn
to write better. For this reason we expect the main audience for this document
to be well-prepared college writing teachers and college writing program
administrators. We have chosen to write in their professional language.
Among such readers, terms such as "rhetorical," "genre," and "text" convey
a rich and specific understanding. To aid other informed readers, the final
version will include appendices with specific examples showing, in context,
how these terms are used.
These statements describe only what the drafters expect to find at the
end of first-year composition, at most schools a required general education
course or sequence of courses. As writers move beyond the first-year course,
their writing abilities do not merely "increase." Rather, students' abilities
both diversify along disciplinary and professional lines and move into
whole new levels where expected outcomes statements would expand, multiply,
and diverge. Still, each statement of outcomes is followed by suggestions
for further work that builds on these outcomes. These suggestions indicate
not only that some institutions may aim to go beyond these outcomes even
for first-year writers but also that writing education needs to continue
throughout students' college careers. The suggestions also demonstrate
what further abilities can be developed upon this base.
Rhetorical Knowledge
By the end of first year composition, students should be able to
-
Focus on a purpose
-
Recognize different audiences and their specific needs
-
Recognize differences in communicative situations and respond appropriately
to those different situations
-
Use conventions of format, structure, and language appropriate to the purpose
of the texts they write
-
Adopt appropriate voice, tone, and level of formality
-
Have a sense of what genres are and how they differ
-
Know that different genres have different rhetorical purposes
-
Write in several genres
-
Acquire the ability to treat the same information in multiple formats
Faculty in all disciplines can build on this preparation by helping students
learn
-
The main features of writing in particular fields
-
The main uses of writing in particular fields
-
The expectations of readers of writing in particular fields
Critical Thinking, Reading, and Writing
By the end of first year composition, students should be able to
-
Use writing and reading for inquiry, learning, thinking, and communicating
-
Learn the steps necessary to carry out a writing assignment or task, including
locating, evaluating, analyzing, and synthesizing appropriate primary and
secondary sources
-
Investigate, report, and document existing knowledge, as well as knowledge
students develop themselves
Faculty in all disciplines can build on this preparation by helping students
learn
-
The uses of writing as a thinking method as well as a communicative performance
-
The interactions among critical thinking, critical reading, language, and
writing
-
The relationships among language, knowledge, culture, history, and politics
in particular disciplines and cultures
Processes
By the end of first year composition, students should
-
Be aware that it usually takes multiple drafts to create and complete a
successful text
-
Understand that writing is an on-going process that permits writers to
use later invention and re-thinking to improve all aspects of what they
are writing
-
Develop strategies for generating, revising, editing, and proof-reading
texts, as appropriate within the development of a specific text
-
Select appropriate language for successful texts, recognizing both sources
and patterns of conventions for particular audiences and purposes
-
Understand the collaborative and social aspects of writing processes
-
Learn to critique their own and others' writing
-
Learn to balance the advantages of relying on others with the responsibility
of doing their part
-
Use a variety of media, including particularly standard computerized media,
in ways that permit them to make their writing acceptable to a wide variety
of readers
Faculty in all disciplines can build on this preparation by helping students
learn
-
To build final results in stages
-
To review work-in-progress in collaborative peer groups for purposes other
than editing
-
To save extensive editing for after invention and development work has
been done very completely
-
To use the media, including especially computerized media, commonly used
to engage in communicative transactions in particular fields
Knowledge of Conventions
By the end of first year composition, students should
-
Develop knowledge of genre conventions ranging from structure and paragraphing
to tone and mechanics
-
Acquire knowledge and conventions for different kinds of writing and occasions
for writing
-
Practice appropriate means of documenting the knowledge they incorporate
into their texts
-
Control such surface features as syntax, grammar, punctuation, and spelling.
Faculty in all disciplines can build on this preparation by helping students learn
- The ways in which particular disciplines differ from others in conventions
of usage and documentation
- How better outcomes in conventions actually can be achieved
- The main conventions that are valued by writers in particular fields,
especially conventions of specialized vocabulary, format, and documentation
Return
to Main menu | Return to the Outcomes
Drafts | Return to the Outcomes History
|